The Alternate Reality is a world where Orange never existed. Liam the Leprechaun tricked him into wishing he was never born after seeing Pear kissing Passion Fruit (it was really her sister Mandy, but they look exactly the same) in order to get revenge for not being invited to his Cristmas party.
- Alternate Pear (he is shy and doesn't have any friends, Orange needed to "pull him out of his shell")
- Alternate Passion Fruit (dating alternate Midget Apple)
- Alternate Midget Apple (dating alternate Passion Fruit)
- Alternate Marshmallow (killed by Hot Cocoa)
- Alternate Peach (alternate Pear's choice for a girlfriend)
- Alternate Grapefruit (injured)