Orange sees two lists on the fridge, which he thinks are varsity team lists, but he soon finds out, with Pear's help, that they are truly recipes, and 'kitchen carnage' begins. After a Strawberry, two Kiwis, and a head of Lettuce are killed, Pear notices that all of these slaughtered characters had been talking with them. He reasons that if they remain silent, the food on the list will be spared. However, when the Apple on the list becomes a jerk, they decide to talk to him and let him die, which they watch, still in horror. The episode ends with Marshmallow and Midget Apple cheering for 'Team Smoothie', and when Orange looks upset, they wonder if they missed the game. After the end, the episode displays an advertisement for the Kitchen Carnage game.