Orange wishes that he was never born because he saw Pear and Passion (actually Mandy) kissing each other. He then meets Mistletoe, who teleports them into a dimension where they see what would happen if he was never born. He sees Pear acting shy around others. Midget Apple and Passion dating, and Marshmallow getting put in a cup of hot cocoa. Orange finds out that Mistletoe is actually Liam the Leprechaun in disguise, and they have a truce for the holidays (he did this all because he wasn't invited to the Christmas party). After this, Liam teleports them back to the real world where Orange discovers that Pear was kissing Mandy, Passion's twin sister. Orange is happy to have them in his life despite being such an annoyance, but then Marshmallow really did get dropped in hot cocoa. He survives though, and everyone laughs while they take a group photo, which is presented as a greeting card at the end of the episode.
Orange sings a song with the lyrics "Jingle bells, Marshmallow smells, Midget Apple is really small! Orange is cool 'cause he rules and Pear looks like a ball!" He then sees Marshmallow and Midget Apple playing with a Xerox machine. They are copying Midget Apple's butt. Orange then asks if they wanted to hear his song again, but Midget Apple declines.
Orange then asks Grandpa Lemon if he wanted to sing a song. Grandpa Lemon replies, but almost immediately falls back to sleep. Orange then sees Pear and Passion. Then Pear and Passion kissed, causing Orange to wish he was never born. Mistletoe, however, grants the wish, taking Orange to 'the world without Orange'. Orange sees Marshmallow and Grandpa Lemon, Pear trying to talk to a peach, and Midget Apple dating Passion Fruit. Mistletoe constantly chants "Behold", but until Marshmallow is picked up and killed from a mug of hot cocoa. Orange becomes saddened, but Mistletoe says "Oh! Way-to-cocoa!" But later, he was revealed to be Liam the Leprechaun to disguise, who was angry because Orange failed to invite him to the party.
After they unanimously agree that he could go to the party, they return to the real world. Orange is surprised to see Marshmallow alive and Pear changed. Orange then meets Mandy, after mistaking Passion kissing Pear. But Marshmallow is picked up, and truly dropped into a mug of hot cocoa. Everybody becomes saddened because of this, until they realize that Marshmallow thought it was a "hot tub full of love". Everybody laughs, and they take a group photo. The episode cuts to the group photo, which then is minimized, revealing the Fruity Question of the Day.