Annoying Saw 2: The Annoying Death Trap is the forty-first episode in the series and this episode marks the first appearance of Marshmallow. It is a sequel to Annoying Saw. Unlike its predecessor, no one got killed by Jigsaw's death trap.
Jigsaw hires Orange as his apprentice to annoy a marshmallow to death. However, Marshmallow and Orange ended quickly becoming friends and started to muck around annoying each other with jokes, before Jigsaw decides to chop Marshmallow in half but the knife cannot go through Marshmallow, instead tickling him. Jigsaw gets angry and burns Marshmallow, but only the top of him burns and he still feels happy. Eventually, Jigsaw fires Orange and leaves, while Marshmallow and Orange still make jokes. Meanwhile a block of chocolate and a graham cracker say they didn't like where this was headed. Eventually, Charlie the Drunk Guinea Pig shows up to scare them with a chainsaw. (It is possible Charlie also killed them)