|Death||one side knifed by a butter knife, other half survived|
|First Appearance||Rolling in the Dough|
Butter was a minor character who only appeared in Rolling in the Dough. He was portrayed by Robert Jennings. When his name is mentioned out, he is confused and Dane Boedigheimer ends up taking the right half of him with a butter knife to be spread across Heel. His other half survived however, but his current fate is unknown. It is also unknown if he is the same butter that greased loaf in the pan making him Heel. Apparently Butter is not knifed because he is butter.
- "Huh?" (screams)
- "My face! My beautiful face!"