Gender Male
Played by Robert Jennings
Death Knifed, eaten
First Appearance Rolling in the Dough

Butter was a minor character who only appeared in Rolling in the Dough. Heel had asked if it was hot in the kitchen or just him feeling warm from being toasted, and Orange suggested that they asked Butter. Butter was confused as to what Orange was talking about, until he was halved by a butter knife. His left half is then smeared all over Heel.